deadlines amuse me

exploring how the world works and why it works that way …

Editor tired of J profs (like me) bashing newspapers

with one comment

An editor for a Lee Enterprises newspaper in Wisconsin took me and other journalism professors to task last week for criticizing corporately owned newspapers. While I didn’t appreciate assumptions he made about me, he raises points about modern newspapering that deserve wider circulation.

See Randolph D. Brant’s piece at E&P or read on …

J-School Profs Wrong to ‘Bash’ Modern Newspapers

An editor takes issue with an E&P column that raised questions about today’s newsrooms and corporate control: “I, for one, am getting sick and tired of disaffected former journalists bashing us from their academic retirements.”

By Randolph D. Brandt

(August 18, 2005) — As I was reading Denny Wilkins’ column this morning (E&P Online, Aug. 15), I was hearing members of my newsroom staff laughing and talking excitedly about one of the many good stories that will appear in my newspaper tomorrow and on the Web page today.

Unlike Denny Wilkins, who is now a professor at a journalism school, I’ve been in newsrooms for the past 15 years. Maybe he ought to come back and find out what it’s really all about these days.

I, for one, am getting sick and tired of disaffected former journalists whose careers didn’t work out for them bashing us from their academic retirements.

Just imagine if professors at M.I.T. or Drexel taught their students that all they could look forward to in their careers was working for lousy, money-grubbing technology firms, design conglomerates, and architects. They’d last about a day!

Why do we tolerate these people poisoning the minds of the young people that we often have to re-educate so we can then offer them worthwhile work, professional fulfillment, and growth in their careers?

The trades seem full these days with such newspaper bashing, particularly aimed against group ownership for some reason.

Sure, group ownership means more accountability, but it also means a fuller range of training and career opportunities, a larger network of support for reporters and editors, more reader and market research to better understand our audiences, and a greater freedom from the sacred-cow restrictions that often accompany locally owned, family operations.

There are strengths and weaknesses under both types of operations, but it horrifies me to think that newsrooms in general and particularly newsrooms at group-owned newspapers are being mischaracterized each day in our j-schools by professors perhaps more concerned with settling an imagined score than preparing students for their careers.

Maybe it’s time for some of the big industry players to endow some journalism chairs so both sides of this story get told.

Randolph D. Brandt is editor of the The Journal Times of Racine, Wis., a Lee Enterprises paper.


Written by Dr. Denny Wilkins

August 23, 2005 at 1:56 pm

Posted in Uncategorized

One Response

Subscribe to comments with RSS.

  1. Glad Mr. Brandt’s experience with group ownership has been good. I can find him others – who are currently in newsrooms! — who would beg to differ.


    August 26, 2005 at 4:32 pm

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: